• Post-Capitalist Society Home
  • The Robot Economy
  • The Excellent Situation

Slouching Towards Dystopia

The Danger of Misunderstanding the Revolution

  • Home
  • About
  • This Is The Revolution
  • This Is The Enemy
  • This Is The Battlefield
  • This Is The Weaponry

About Slouching Towards Dystopia

One Nation Under CCTV by Tom Blackwell via flicker

One Nation Under CCTV by Tom Blackwell via flicker

We may be living in technologically revolutionary times but there is no assurance that the socioeconomic changes these technologies bring will be for the better. Technological dynamism does not equal technological determinism. Revolutionary new technologies will not automatically usher in utopia. How things fall-out will depend on how we act; how we “become consciousness of this conflict and fight it out.”

This section explores the possibility that we will get it wrong.

This single greatest threat before us arises from reactionary forces which will seek to retain hegemonic control of the new forces of production. The single greatest error we can make is to accept the argument that the relations of capitalist production should be preserved in the new social formation. I call this mistake the great hamartia – the tragic misstep, the fatal flaw. It gives birth to myriad false solutions and deceptive proposals for how we should respond to the changes in our economic base.

If we agree to allow a small, elite class to own and control all the productive apparatus of society while the rest of us sink into the role of passive consumers, a new type of dispossessed lumpenproletariat, we will create a dystopia of exacerbated class antagonism and inequality.

The new Galtian overlords will rely on ever more sophisticated surveillance methods and crowd-control techniques to maintain their hegemony. They will control all the repressive powers of the state. They will be the state. Resistance will be futile; two plus two will equal five.

Tragically, we will have created this type of society for ourselves at precisely the one time in history when a classless, democratic alternative was finally within reach. Everything cascades from that one tragic misstep of preserving capitalist class structures.

I know this is not easy to grasp. My concern for brevity in this introduction has, perhaps, caused me to be somewhat hyperbolic. That’s why I’ve created this entire section to explore in sober detail the tendencies in our present society which are contributing to our slouch towards this dystopia.

Ultimately, the greatest threat to a free and open democratic society may be our own apathy and ignorance. By dragging these subjects out into the light I hope to increase understanding and develop defenses against them. An informed citizenry is still the best defense against tyranny.

 

Something To Think About:

The capitalist or any other order of things may evidently break down - or economic and social evolution may outgrow it - and yet the socialist phoenix may fail to rise from the ashes. There may be chaos and, unless we define as socialism any non-chaotic alternative to capitalism, there are other possibilities.

Joseph A. Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy

We proceed from an actual economic fact.

The worker becomes all the poorer the more wealth he produces, the more his production increases in power and size. The worker becomes an ever cheaper commodity the more commodities he creates. The devaluation of the world of men is in direct proportion to the increasing value of the world of things. Labor produces not only commodities; it produces itself and the worker as a commodity – and this at the same rate at which it produces commodities in general.

- Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844. Karl Marx

The Sane Society

Man today is confronted with the most fundamental choice; not that between Capitalism and Communism, but that between robotism (of both the capitalist and communist variety), or Humanistic Communitarian Socialism. Most facts seem to indicate that he is choosing robotism, and that means, in the long run, insanity and destruction. But all these facts are not strong enough to destroy faith in man's reason, good will, and sanity. As long as we can think of other alternatives, we are not lost; as long as we can consult together and plan together, we can hope. But, indeed, the shadows are lengthening; the voices of insanity are becoming louder. We are in reach of achieving a state of humanity which corresponds to the vision of our great teachers; yet we are in danger of the destruction of all civilization, or of robotization.

- Erich Fromm, The Sane Society (1955)

Creative Commons License
Original articles on postcapitalistsociety.net are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in